Journal of Experimental
Biosciences
Manuscript Reviewer Evaluation Form
1. Manuscript Information
Manuscript ID:
__________________________
Title of Manuscript:
__________________________________________
Date of Review:
__________________________
2. Reviewer Declaration
Confidentiality Agreement:
☐ I confirm that I will maintain full confidentiality
of this manuscript and will not share or use its content for personal or
professional purposes.
Conflict of Interest:
☐ I declare that I have no conflict of interest
regarding this manuscript
☐ I declare a potential conflict of interest (please
specify):
3. Evaluation of the
Manuscript
Please assess the manuscript
using the following criteria:
|
Criteria
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
Fair
|
Poor
|
|
Scientific validity &
methodology
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
|
Originality & novelty
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
|
Clarity of presentation
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
|
Organization & structure
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
|
Relevance to journal scope
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
☐
|
4. Detailed Comments
A. Strengths of the
Manuscript:
B. Weaknesses / Limitations:
C. Specific Suggestions for
Improvement:
(Please provide constructive and actionable feedback)
5. Ethical Considerations
Any signs of plagiarism: ☐
Yes ☐ No
Ethical concerns (if any):
6. Recommendation
Please select one:
☐ Accept as it is
☐ Accept with minor revisions
☐ Major revision required
☐ Reject
7. Additional Confidential
Comments to the Editor (Optional)
(Not shared with authors)
8. Reviewer Confirmation
I confirm that:
This review is objective,
unbiased, and constructive
I have avoided personal criticism
I have completed this review
within the assigned timeframe
Reviewer Name (optional):
__________________________
Signature: __________________________
Date: __________________________